Refine Search
Map
Sort by
$215,000
3 Beds ⋅ 3 Baths
Discover an inviting ranch-style residence at 1605 Cedar DR, NEWCASTLE, IN. Built in 1980, this single-family home offers 2359 square feet of comfortable living space, ready for you to move in and make it your own. The kitchen is thoughtfully designed with a peninsula, offering both functionality and a welcoming atmosphere for culinary pursuits. There is also an office off of the kitchen. This property features a private yard, providing a serene outdoor retreat. An attached garage offers convenience and additional storage. A bonus room off of the garage offers more storage or flexibility for your hobbies. For everyday ease, a dedicated laundry room is also included. With 3 bedrooms and 2 full bathrooms. The primary bedroom is very large with its private bathroom. This home is designed for comfortable living. Schedule a private showing to experience the charm and functionality of this appealing property.

1605 Cedar Drive, New Castle

Listing courtesy of REMAX ONE.

$45,900
2 Beds ⋅ 1 Baths
This 2-bedroom home with a possible third bedroom upstairs offers plenty of opportunity for the right buyer. With a new HVAC system already installed and a new breaker box in place, some of the major updates have been started. The home needs drywall work and the electrical project completed, making it an ideal investment property or renovation project. Bring your ideas and transform this home into something special

1018 S 15th Street, New Castle

Listing courtesy of Legacy Real Estate Partners.

$950,000
4 Beds ⋅ 3 Baths
Set on 23.46 acres in Henry County just minutes from New Castle, this property offers comfortable living, recreation, and privacy in one East Central Indiana setting. A private drive winds past a huge stocked pond before arriving at a custom home tucked along mature woods with water views. The home offers approximately 5,007 sq ft with 4 bedrooms, 2.5 baths, a large bonus room, loft, and flexible living spaces. The open main level features vaulted ceilings, hardwood floors, a floor-to-ceiling stone fireplace, and large windows overlooking the pond and landscape. The updated kitchen includes new countertops and appliances with an adjoining dining area designed to maximize natural light and views. The main-level primary suite includes a spacious bedroom, walk-in closet, and dual-sink bath with walk-in shower and soaking area. Upstairs features three additional bedrooms, full bath, loft overlooking the main living area, utility room, and a large bonus room. Built with 2x6 exterior construction for added insulation and strength, the home includes an exceptionally clean attached garage with newer HVAC, utility sink, and access to a waterproofed crawl space. Outdoor living is highlighted by a wraparound deck spanning three sides of the home overlooking the pond, woods, and acreage. The property includes established trails and approximately 6 acres ideal for food plots, pasture, or habitat development. Miscanthus grass along the road enhances privacy. The pristine pond is stocked with largemouth bass and bluegill, reaches depths of approximately 15-20 feet, and includes structure, dock, beach area, gazebo, and fire pit gathering space. A 40x60 barn provides significant storage and workshop space with an attached office area. Conveniently located 5 miles from New Castle, 20 miles from Muncie, 30 miles from Anderson, and 50 miles from Indianapolis.

938 N County Road 275 E, New Castle

Listing courtesy of Whitetail Properties.

$221,000
3 Beds ⋅ 2 Baths
Imagine 3640 Red River Rd, recently updated with fresh interior paint, setting a pristine tone. The living area features a fireplace, complementing a kitchen equipped with all stainless steel appliances and backsplash. An accessible deck extends to a fully fenced backyard, providing functional outdoor space. This refreshed residence provides exceptional comfort and outdoor living-a true must-see. Included 100-Day Home Warranty with buyer activation

3640 Red River Road, New Castle

Listing courtesy of Opendoor Brokerage LLC.

$144,900
4 Beds ⋅ 2 Baths
Discover the charm of 1549 Thornburg ST, NEWCASTLE, IN, a welcoming single-family residence built in 1900, offering 1872 square feet of move-in-ready living space. This inviting home seamlessly blends historic character with comfortable modern living. The heart of this home, the kitchen, features a distinctive wainscot wall, creating an atmosphere perfect for culinary creativity and casual gatherings. One of the four bedrooms offers the convenience of an ensuite bathroom, providing a private retreat. This bedroom also showcases classic hardwood flooring, adding a touch of timeless elegance. Beyond the main living areas, the property extends its appeal with a functional basement, offering additional space for storage or future customization. The private yard, spanning 10542 square feet, provides a serene outdoor setting for relaxation or entertaining. Experience the unique appeal of this property and envision your future within its walls.

1549 Thornburg Street, New Castle

Listing courtesy of Rhodes Realty, LLC.

$179,000
Located in the heart of downtown New Castle on Broad Street, this versatile commercial property offers excellent visibility and accessibility. Featuring both Broad Street and Fleming Street access, the spacious layout includes a total of 4,630 SF + basement. The main floor has a front unit with 2,165 SF, large display room, office / storage room, half bath, and basement access. The rear unit offers 1,300 square feet with a warehouse-style area, office / storage room, half bath, and separate entrance. The unique set up makes this property ideal for a variety of business opportunities. Adding to its appeal is a second floor apartment with private entry, Downtown Broad Street views, 4 rooms and 1/2 bathroom. Recent updates to this building include the roof, second story windows, electrical, HVAC and facade.

1334 Broad Street, New Castle

Listing courtesy of Real Broker, LLC.

$249,900
3 Beds ⋅ 2 Baths
Don't miss your chance to own a home on one of New Castle's most picturesque streets! This charming property offers the perfect blend of timeless character and everyday comfort, featuring three spacious bedrooms and two full bathrooms. From the moment you step inside, you'll appreciate the beautiful hardwood floors throughout, adding warmth and elegance to every room. The inviting layout also includes a cozy family room in the basement, creating the perfect space for movie nights, entertaining, or simply relaxing. Just beyond the main living area, a screened back porch offers the ideal place to enjoy your morning coffee or unwind in the evenings while overlooking your own private retreat. Step outside to discover your backyard oasis - perfect for gardening, hosting gatherings, or enjoying peaceful moments surrounded by nature. Opportunities like this don't come along often. Full of charm, space, and character, this home is a rare find in one of New Castle's most desirable locations.

1121 Woodlawn Drive, New Castle

Listing courtesy of Epique Inc.

$54,900
2 Beds ⋅ 1 Baths
Investment opportunity with built-in income potential - or a great option for a future owner occupant! This 2 bedroom, 1 bath home offers a great chance to add to your portfolio, start investing in real estate, or to make it your own. Outside, you'll find a nice yard with plenty of space to enjoy. Newer metal roof, newer water heater, newer high efficiency gas furnace, entry and storm doors have been updated, newer front and rear porches and roofs. There is a long term tenant in place who would love to stay."Motivated Seller"

722 N 24th Street, New Castle

Listing courtesy of Legacy Real Estate Partners.

$155,000
Investor Opportunity in Downtown New Castle! Opportunity awaits with this 6-unit apartment property located in downtown New Castle. Major exterior improvements and key system updates have already been completed, making this an ideal value-add investment for the next owner to finish and start leveraging rental income. Updates to the property's exterior accentuate a strong curb appeal and may reduce future maintenance concerns. Additional improvements have been made to the electrical and plumbing systems, providing a solid start for continued renovations and stabilization. With its favorable location near downtown amenities, shopping, dining, and local employers, this multi-unit property offers excellent potential for long-term cash flow and portfolio growth. Whether you're an experienced investor or looking to expand your rental holdings, this is a rare opportunity to complete a partially updated income-producing property in a growing market. Schedule your showing today and bring this investment Home!

2702 Broad Street, New Castle

Listing courtesy of Keller Williams Indpls Metro N.

$64,999
2 Beds ⋅ 1 Baths
Opportunity knocks with this property at 1621 R Avenue in New Castle! This home offers a fantastic chance for investors or buyers ready to bring their vision to life. With some care and creativity, this property could be transformed into a cozy residence or a valuable addition to any investment portfolio. The standout feature of this home is the oversized yard, offering a wonderful space for outdoor living, gardening, or just relaxing in the fresh air. The possibilities are endless for those who value room to stretch out and customize their surroundings. If you're looking for a project with great promise, 1621 R Avenue is the perfect canvas. Don't miss the chance to explore all this home has to offer and turn it into something truly special.

1621 R Avenue, New Castle

Listing courtesy of FC Tucker Richmond.

$70,000
2 Beds ⋅ 1 Baths
Investor special with tons of potential! This property is ready for your vision and would make a great addition to an investment portfolio or renovation project. Conveniently located in New Castle with easy access to local amenities.

1718 Irvin Street, New Castle

Listing courtesy of Hemrick Property Group Inc..

$227,900
4 Beds ⋅ 1 Baths
Move in ready two story located at the edge of town features new metal roof new privacy fence and new storage shed. 4 bedrooms (1 down 3 up) 1 extra large bathroom 2 large front rooms great kitchen with black wooden cabinets, solid surface countertops, stainless appliances plus kitchen island. Main level laundry mud room includes washer and dryer. Side deck and covered front porch. A great family home sitting at the edge of town. Survey provided for house and original lot. Property includes additional 3 lots behind the property.

921 N 14th Street, New Castle

Listing courtesy of F.C. Tucker/Crossroads.

$89,000
2 Beds ⋅ 1 Baths
1324 Thornburg Street in New Castle, Indiana, presents an outstanding opportunity for homeowners and investors alike. This home does require repairs, but it holds remarkable potential to become a charming residence or a profitable investment property. Packed with amenities, the house features a gas fireplace, new pex plumbing, and a convenient laundry chute. The spacious basement, complete with a pull-in garage, provides ample storage and versatile space for workshop projects or recreation. The home offers a layout ideal for customization to suit your needs. Located in a well-established neighborhood, the property enjoys proximity to local schools, parks, and essential services. Whether you're seeking a place to call your own or looking to make a strategic investment.

1324 Thornburg Street, New Castle

Listing courtesy of FC Tucker Richmond.

$82,499
2 Beds ⋅ 1 Baths
Welcome to your new home or investment opportunity! This home boasts a great location and ample-sized rooms, making it a perfect investment opportunity or a wonderful place to call your own. The property features a one-car attached garage and a spacious work area in the basement, ideal for projects and storage. Enjoy the outdoors with a covered front porch and a fenced-in yard, perfect for pets and outdoor activities. The yard also offers plenty of space for cookouts and gatherings. Don't miss out on this incredible opportunity to own a home with so much potential

1324 J Avenue, New Castle

Listing courtesy of FC Tucker Richmond.

$65,000
5 Beds ⋅ 2 Baths
Introducing a fantastic opportunity at 422 S 18th St, New Castle! This versatile property is perfect for a family home or a duplex investment. Situated on a corner lot, the house is in great overall condition and boasts spacious, well-lit rooms that provide a warm and inviting atmosphere. The massive 44x44 garage is ideal for mechanics, storage, or even a small independent business. The home features a stairway to the upper unit, which is also accessible from the first floor inside the lower unit, offering flexibility in how the property can be used. The location is superb, with a nice-sized yard perfect for hanging out and enjoying outdoor activities. Great shape, this exceptional deal is a fantastic opportunity for anyone looking for a valuable investment or a cozy family home

422 S 18th Street, New Castle

Listing courtesy of FC Tucker Richmond.

$982,500
+/-78.6 acres of land on the edge of New Castle. This could be a great investment for continued use as farmland or for possible development. With +/- 71 acres of tillable land and approximately 5 acres of mature woods, the site is ideal for farming, recreation, or future expansion.This is a unique opportunity for those looking for a versatile piece of land in a desirable location.

2600 S State Road 103, New Castle

Listing courtesy of F.C. Tucker/Crossroads.

$94,900
2 Beds ⋅ 1 Baths
This single-family residence is not just ready for you, it's practically winking a friendly "come on in!" With two delightful bedrooms, there's plenty of space for dreams to take flight, whether you're planning a cozy personal retreat or a vibrant guest haven. Outside, a welcoming porch invites you to kick back with a cool drink and enjoy the fresh air. And with a sprawling double lot with a large detached garage with built in loft, your outdoor possibilities are as boundless as your imagination!

2301 S 19th Street, New Castle

Listing courtesy of eXp Realty LLC.

$249,900
4 Beds ⋅ 2 Baths
This older home is being sold as-is and will require repair and updating. The property offers an opportunity for buyers to restore and customize a home in a truly exceptional setting. Located on 3.7 acres and directly adjoining Westwood Park and lake, the property enjoys expansive valley views and a rare combination of privacy, natural beauty, and potential. The traditional farmhouse features up to four bedrooms, one and a half baths, classic hardwood floors and trim, an oversized detached garage with automatic openers, and a full basement. Beautiful foliage throughout spring, summer, and autumn.

2645 S Greensboro Pike, New Castle

Listing courtesy of RE/MAX First Integrity.

$119,900
2 Beds ⋅ 1 Baths
Welcome to 1122 S. 21st St., a cozy two-bedroom, one-bath bungalow perfectly situated in the center of New Castle. This home features a practical layout with a combined living and dining area ideal for everyday living and entertaining. The eat-in kitchen offers a comfortable space for meals and gatherings. Both bedrooms are well-sized, and the full bath is conveniently located. Outside, enjoy a spacious two-car garage-perfect for storage or hobby space. With its central location, you'll have easy access to local shops, schools, and amenities. Whether you're a first-time buyer, downsizing, or investing, this home is full of potential!

1122 S 21st Street, New Castle

Listing courtesy of F.C. Tucker/Crossroads.

$125,000
2 Beds ⋅ 1 Baths
Situated at 431 N 14th ST in NEWCASTLE, IN, USA, this single family residence is an inviting home, meticulously prepared and ready for immediate occupancy. The living room serves as a captivating heart for the residence, distinguished by a stately fireplace, offering warmth and a focal point for gatherings. Overhead, an elegant coffered ceiling introduces a sophisticated architectural detail, elevating the room's character and creating an atmosphere of refined comfort. In the kitchen you'll find a naturally lit spaced perfect for meal prepping especially with the included appliances. This delightful single story dwelling offers two peaceful bedrooms, providing serene retreats for rest and rejuvenation, complemented by a well-appointed full bathroom designed for convenience. A dedicated laundry room simplifies daily routines, while an exterior shed offers valuable additional storage capacity for personal belongings or outdoor equipment. The manageable living area of 816 square feet ensures comfort without excess.

431 N 14th Street, New Castle

Listing courtesy of Keller Williams Indy Metro Partners.

$42,900
2 Beds ⋅ 1 Baths
This is a 2-bedroom, 1-bathroom home with a 1-car garage. It is conveniently located near parks, an aquatic center, and ball fields. Please note that this property is a fixer-upper that needs TLC and is being sold "as is"

1222 Webster Avenue, New Castle

Listing courtesy of eXp Realty, LLC.

$99,900
2 Beds ⋅ 1 Baths
Updated 2-bedroom home with immediate possession available! This property features numerous recent improvements including newer roof shingles, vinyl siding, vinyl replacement windows, and updated kitchen cabinets with granite countertops. Interior highlights include vinyl plank flooring throughout the main living areas and carpeted bedrooms for added comfort. The living room offers an electric fireplace, creating a warm and inviting space. The eat-in kitchen provides ample cabinet space and functionality, along with a convenient main-level laundry room. The bathroom has been tastefully updated with a claw foot tub, subway tile, and shiplap accents, blending modern updates with classic charm. Additional features include a partial basement with a 90+ high-efficiency gas furnace and central air, a one-car detached garage with built-in storage, and a partially fenced backyard. A great opportunity for owner-occupants or investors alike!

2029 Lincoln Avenue, New Castle

Listing courtesy of Taflinger Real Estate Group.

$349,000
3 Beds ⋅ 2 Baths
Beautiful 2100 sq ft ranch style home offering 3 bedrooms and 2 full baths. Enjoy an open concept layout connecting the living, dining, and kitchen areas. The updated kitchen features soft close cabinets and a large walk in pantry for ample storage. A spacious Great room with a cozy fireplace provides additional gathering space. The property includes a 2 car attached garage, a 3 car detached garage and a large 40x52 pole barn. Ideal for storage, hobbies, or a workshop. Situated on a generous 0.83 acre lot. You'll also love the covered front porch and covered back patio for relaxing or entertaining outdoors.

1334 S Onyx Court, New Castle

Listing courtesy of Berkshire Hathaway Home.

$675,000
Historic presence, bold scale, and the kind of opportunity that rarely comes along, this standout New Castle property delivers it all. Built in 1847 by Mason Livezey for the Eli Murphy family, this two-story structure offers over 4,100 square feet and sits on a hard to find 0.75 acre lot right in the heart of town. From the moment you arrive, the architectural character makes an impression-timeless, substantial, and ready for its next chapter. The heavy lifting has already been done, giving you a strong head start. All five chimneys have been completely rebuilt, a new roof with slate look shingles adds both durability and style, and fresh interior and exterior paint create a clean, refreshed feel throughout. New flooring has been installed, along with new shutters and soffit, while the columns have been reworked to ensure long-term structural integrity, preserving the look while strengthening the foundation for what comes next. And then there's the feature that truly sets this property apart, its dedicated parking lot. In a downtown setting where parking is often limited, this is a rare and valuable asset that adds everyday convenience and long-term appeal. With its size, history, and extensive updates already in place, this property offers the kind of flexibility and presence that invites creativity. Whether you're envisioning a residential restoration, a business venture, or a blend of both, this is a space with stories behind it, and plenty more waiting to be written.

321 S Main Street, New Castle

Listing courtesy of RE/MAX First Integrity.

$675,000
Step into a true transformation opportunity at 1214 Broad Street, planted right in the center of downtown New Castle, where every great revitalization story begins. This former Town Tavern space delivers instant character with its original bar anchoring the main level, creating a natural focal point for a reimagined hospitality concept, retail experience, or hybrid venue. Behind the scenes, the heavy lifting has already started with a new roof, new first-floor HVAC system, and updated storefront windows and exterior doors, giving you a strong foundation to build on. What truly sets this property apart is its attached parking lot - an uncommon advantage in this downtown corridor that adds both function and long-term value. Upstairs, the second and third floors offer unfinished space ready for a complete design vision - think loft-style residences, studio spaces, or income-producing units layered above your main-level concept. This is more than a property, it's a canvas with structure, story, and location already in place. For those with an eye for design and a plan for execution, 1214 Broad Street is ready to be taken from raw potential to a standout destination.

1214 Broad Street, New Castle

Listing courtesy of RE/MAX First Integrity.

$15,999
Wooded Tract with Convenient City Access Nestled on a 0.55-acre tract, this heavily wooded property offers a serene and private retreat while being conveniently located. With frontage along Garner Street, the land benefits from easy access to city utilities, ensuring modern conveniences are within reach. To the west, enjoy the proximity to a public walking trail, ideal for recreation and relaxation. The eastern boundary features two neighbors, while expansive farmland lies just beyond the trail to the west, providing picturesque views and a sense of open space. Whether you're looking to build your dream home or invest in land, this property combines nature, convenience, and potential.

00 N Main Street, New Castle

Listing courtesy of Listwithfreedom.com.

$339,900
3 Beds ⋅ 2 Baths
Welcome home to 402 Luellen Drive, a brand-new gem crafted by Bridgenorth Homes. Showcasing the highly sought-after Bristol floor plan, this 3-bedroom, 2-bathroom residence offers 1,469 square feet of beautifully designed, functional living space. Step through the arched entryway and into a bright, inviting open-concept layout bathed in natural light from an abundance of windows. The spacious living area flows seamlessly with the dining room and a modern kitchen built for entertaining. The kitchen features sleek solid surface countertops, an undermount sink, a walk-in pantry, and a large center island with bar seating. Just off the dining area, you'll find a covered porch-the perfect spot for enjoying your morning coffee or winding down in the evening.The smart split-bedroom floor plan ensures privacy. The primary suite serves as a true retreat, boasting a generous walk-in closet and a beautiful en suite bathroom complete with a vanity and zero-entry shower. Two additional spacious bedrooms share a beautifully appointed second full bathroom. Additional interior highlights include a separate, dedicated laundry room for everyday convenience and a massive 3-car attached garage providing ample space for vehicles, storage, or a workshop. Located in a lovely, newly developed community, residents enjoy access to a brand-new clubhouse, walking trails, and close proximity to the local YMCA. Don't miss your chance to be the very first owner of this pristine home!

402 Luellen Way, New Castle

Listing courtesy of F.C. Tucker/Crossroads.

$250,000
3 Beds ⋅ 2 Baths
Check out this completely updated home near Riley Elementary. 3 Bedrooms, 2 bath ranch home. Updated kitchen with appliances. Attached garage, Privacy fenced yard with large storage shed. Immediate possession.

1127 Hickory Lane, New Castle

Listing courtesy of RE/MAX First Integrity.

$529,900
Looking to build residential or commercial? 31 acres give you the country feel yet close to town and main thoroughfares. 27/31 acres are tillable with a 2 acre pond . Possibilities are endless.

000 S State Road 103, New Castle

Listing courtesy of F.C. Tucker/Crossroads.

$19,900
N 28th St is a street platted but never developed. The owner is currently in negotiations with the city and his neighbors to vacate the alley. 3 city lots each measuring 70x131 for a grand total of 0.632 Acres. City water and sewer available but not connected. Electricity from Duke Energy and Gas from CenterPoint available but not connected. Lots will not be divided.

000 N 28th Street, New Castle

Listing courtesy of F.C. Tucker/Crossroads.

Information Deemed Reliable But Not Guaranteed. © 2026 MIBOR Broker Listing Cooperative