Hensley Homes for Sale

Hensley Homes for Sale

Welcome to Hensley, Indiana – a hidden gem nestled in the heart of Johnson County. This charming region is known for its picturesque landscapes, friendly community, and a rich tapestry of history that invites you to explore. Hensley boasts a serene, rural atmosphere, while still being conveniently located just a short drive from the bustling amenities of nearby towns. With its lush greenery and beautiful parks, it’s the perfect backdrop for outdoor enthusiasts and families alike.

As you consider making Hensley your home, you’ll find a diverse selection of homes for sale that cater to a variety of lifestyles and budgets. From cozy single-family residences to spacious properties with ample land, Hensley offers a range of options that can accommodate your unique needs. Many homes feature modern amenities, while still retaining that charming, small-town feel that makes this area so special.

The community is known for its welcoming spirit, and the local schools are highly regarded, making Hensley an ideal place for families to settle down. Whether you’re looking for a quiet retreat or a vibrant place to raise your children, you’ll find it here.

With homes for sale in Hensley, now is the perfect time to explore this delightful region. Embrace the opportunity to create lasting memories in a neighborhood that feels like home from the moment you arrive. Discover the charm of Hensley, Indiana, and take the first step toward your dream home today!

Newest Hensley Homes for Sale

4 Beds ⋅ 3 Baths

YES, you can have the best of both worlds! Escape to the peace and tranquility of lakeside living while staying conveniently connected to big city amenities. Within a 30 minute drive to DT Indy, you can enjoy sporting events, concerts, and fine dining. OR when adventure calls, head just 30 minutes south to Brown Co State Park and the charming artist community of Nashville, Indiana, where you'll discover miles of hiking and mountain biking trails, horseback riding, wineries, unique boutiques, art galleries, live music, and locally owned restaurants. Nestled on 4+ scenic acres with frontage on a tranquil 8-acre private lake, this 4BR/3BA home offers the perfect balance of privacy and everyday comfort. Rich wood architecture and stained glass transom windows above the private office and formal DR create a stunning first impression, filling the foyer with colorful natural light. The DR features a custom solid wood built-in china cabinet and buffet w/glass display cabinetry, providing beautiful storage for treasured heirlooms, serving pieces, or collectibles! The spacious great room is the heart of the home, where family and friends gather around the cozy fireplace! Lake views await from the main-level primary bedroom w/ensuite bath. Upstairs, features two generously sized bedrooms with multiple large closets and a spacious loft overlooking the main living area. Have some hobbies? The full walkout basement plus detached garage offers incredible potential for additional flex space. Love fishing? Grab your rod and cast into the 8-acre lake just beyond your back porch! Combining custom craftsmanship, rich wood architecture, hardwood floors, stained glass transoms, a built-in dining room buffet, a luxurious main-floor primary suite, walkout basement, private lake frontage, expansive acreage, and an unbeatable location near Brown Co, this property offers far more than a home-it offers a lifestyle where every day feels like a vacation. Welcome home!

6239 W 600 S, Trafalgar

Listing courtesy of Berkshire Hathaway HomeServices.

5 Beds ⋅ 3 Baths

Welcome to 110 N Raymond Ave- where thoughtful design meets playful charm! Just minutes from Indian Creek Schools, the Johnson County Public Library, and the Trafalgar Community Building, you'll enjoy convenient access to local amenities while still feeling right at home. Built in 2019, this 2781 square foot home has been meticulously maintained and is ready to welcome new owners! The kitchen is a culinary playground, with a full center island and walk in pantry. It opens up past the breakfast bar into your dining room. The open concept keeps everyone connected- this is where the party begins! Your guests will love having a place to stay with a full bathroom equipped with a standing shower on the main level. With four additional bedrooms upstairs, and a separate office on the main, space is no concern here! When it's time to unwind, discover your primary ensuite bathroom that feels like a mini-spa retreat. With a double vanity, there's plenty of elbow room, the walk-in shower is perfect for washing away the day's adventures, or relax with a soak in the garden tub. Outside, your private yard is another dream waiting to happen. Gather around the fire pit for marshmallow roasting under the stars, or simply kick back on the patio and soak up the good life. And let's not forget the attached garage and a dedicated laundry room, conveniently upstairs, because even playful living needs a dash of practicality. Ready to explore your new favorite place to play? Book your showing today!

110 N Raymond Avenue, Trafalgar

Listing courtesy of Keller Williams Indy Metro Partners.

3 Beds ⋅ 2 Baths

This charming ranch style home offers 3 bedrooms, 2 full bathrooms, and a comfortable, functional layout designed for easy everyday living. Step inside to find new vinyl plank flooring that gives the home a fresh, updated feel. The spacious great room features a vaulted ceiling, creating an open and inviting atmosphere for relaxing or entertaining. The kitchen includes stainless steel appliances and a cozy breakfast nook for casual dining. The generously sized primary suite offers a private bath and walk in closet, providing a comfortable retreat at the end of the day. Outside, enjoy a spacious fully fenced backyard with plenty of room for outdoor entertaining, pets, gardening, or simply relaxing. The finished 2 car garage adds extra convenience and storage, and immediate possession makes this home even more appealing. Schedule your private showing today and see all this Trafalgar home has to offer!

56 Clear Spring Lane, Trafalgar

Listing courtesy of F.C. Tucker Company.

3 Beds ⋅ 3 Baths

Photos are of the same floor plan; finishes and features may vary. Projected for completion in mid-September 2026, this thoughtfully designed Arbor home in Wood Preserve offers a well-planned two-story layout with the peace of mind of new construction, a builder warranty, and truly turnkey living. This home features an inviting open-concept main level that seamlessly connects the kitchen, dining area, and great room, creating a spacious environment ideal for everyday living and entertaining. A covered front entry and an elevation that blends brick with siding, adds welcoming curb appeal. The primary bedroom suite provides a private retreat with an en-suite bath including a double vanity and spacious shower, while additional bedrooms and a versatile loft offer flexibility for a home office, guest space, or hobbies. A conveniently located laundry room adds to the home's functional layout, while a rear patio extends the living space outdoors for relaxing or entertaining. Wood Preserve is ideally situated in Trafalgar, offering a peaceful setting with convenient access to shopping, dining, parks, and schools, along with easy access to commuter routes. Residents enjoy a quiet community with peaceful common areas and pond views, that blend modern convenience with small-town charm. Learn more today!

704 Braxton Street, Trafalgar

Listing courtesy of Ridgeline Realty, LLC.

3 Beds ⋅ 2 Baths

Photos are of the same floor plan; finishes and features may vary. This thoughtfully designed Arbor home in Wood Preserve offers a well-planned single-level layout with the peace of mind of new construction, a builder warranty, and truly turnkey living. This home features an inviting open-concept design that seamlessly connects the kitchen and great room, creating a spacious environment ideal for everyday living and entertaining. A covered front porch and a front elevation of brick with siding adds welcoming curb appeal. The primary bedroom suite provides a private retreat with an en-suite bath including a double vanity and spacious shower, while additional bedrooms offer flexibility for a home office, guest space, or hobbies. A front flex room offers added versatility for formal dining or additional living space, and a conveniently located laundry room adds to the home's functional layout. A rear patio extends the living space outdoors for relaxing or entertaining. Wood Preserve offers a peaceful setting with convenient access to major roadways, shopping, dining, parks, and everyday amenities, combining a quiet, country-like atmosphere with modern convenience. Learn more today!

685 Braxton Street, Trafalgar

Listing courtesy of Ridgeline Realty, LLC.

3 Beds ⋅ 2 Baths

HEART of TRAFALGAR - SPRING LAKE ESTATES - LIKE NEW: 1300sqft RANCH 3 BED 2.5 BATH completed in 2020, featuring Open Concept Design w/ MASTER: Walk-In Closet, Big Walk-In Shower, Ensuite is Plumbed for Gas Fireplace, NEW CARPET & PAINT; BED 2 & 3: Split Bedroom, Tub & Shower Full Bathroom, W/i Closets, NEW CARPET & PAINT; KITCHEN: Eat-In w Brkfst Area, Pantry, NEW VINYL HW Floor & PAINT, Pendant Lights, Cathedral Ceiling, Lots of Counter & Cabinet Space; LAUNDRY/MUDROOM: Spacious, Private, & 1/2 Bath, New Flooring & Paint; GREAT ROOM: Giant, NEW CARPET & PAINT, Plumbed for 2nd Gas FP, Cathedral Ceiling; FINISHED 2 CAR GARAGE: Service Door & Window for Great Natural Light, Garage Door Opener, Crawl Space Access, Attic Overhead; OUTSIDE: Large Back & Side Yard, Custom Vinyl Privacy Fence, 10x10 Concrete Patio, 12 x16 Minibarn; Home was recently Power Washed, Large Concrete Driveway, Fresh Mulch & No Neighbors Behind on Quiet Cul De Sac Lot; ALSO: Low HOA, Updated Bathrooms, Sparkling Clean, Hardwired Smoke Detectors, Upgrade Windows, Newer ROOF, GUTTERS, SIDING, FURNACE, A/C, WATER HTR, KITCHEN APPLIANCES: 2020, Upgraded Lights and Hunter Ceiling Fans, 1 Mile from Schools, Park, Athletics, Arts, & Easy to the Johnson County Lakes, SR 135, SR 252, Easy to Brown County State Park & Steps away from Casey's & Crowbar!

7 Watson Court, Trafalgar

Listing courtesy of Jeff Paxson Team.

3 Beds ⋅ 4 Baths

Very rare opportunity to live on Lamb Lake with a level front yard and very gently sloping back yard to the lakefront! Over 1 1/2 acres! Great location with private access to the beach! Enjoy joining in at the beach (with shelter house & WiFi and restrooms) or enjoy your own private lakeside dock with lots of boat parking and raised lakefront patio. Beautifully landscaped pathway along the cove waterfront to the dock. Lovely updated custom ranch with finished basement. Gorgeous gourmet kitchen with corian counters, SS appliances, center island, and custom cabinets. Dining area with river rock wood burning fireplace, great room with built-ins and doors opening to multi level back deck overlooking beach and lake. Spacious primary bedroom w/2 closets opens to sunroom, full private bath with walk-in shower, and double sinks. BR2 & BR3 share a full private bath. 1/2 bath for guests on main level. Basement is finished with 2 spacious rooms and a full bath. Laundry located in basement. 2-car garage is oversized and has utility sink and stairs leading to a huge attic area, which could be converted into living space. and ready to move in. Fish, ski, swim, boating, and all types of wildlife just 30 minutes south of Greenwood, and 45 mins to Downtown Indy.

4445 W Pitcher Drive, Trafalgar

Listing courtesy of RE/MAX Advanced Realty.

3 Beds ⋅ 2 Baths

ADORABLE MOVE IN READY! 3 Bedrooms / 2 full Baths / 2 car attached, oversized, finished Garage with service door! This is a super cute RANCH in the sought after small, quaint, community of White Oak Commons in Trafalgar. 9' ceilings throughout the home. Kitchen features: granite counters, stainless steel appliances, gas range/stove, island with bar stool seating area, updated pendant light fixtures over island, and vinyl flooring. Kitchen also has a reverse osmosis system for drinking water. Primary Suite features: double sinks, stand up shower, granite counter tops, and walk-in closet. All Bedrooms have a ceiling fan as well as the Family Room! Carpet in all three Bedrooms is brand new! Washer and Dryer are included! Paid for Water Softener is included. Covered back patio with raised garden beds next to patio. Ring door system will stay with home!

646 N Sobota Way, Trafalgar

Listing courtesy of Weichert REALTORS® Cooper Group Indy.

3 Beds ⋅ 2 Baths

Remodeled top to bottom, this updated home offers 3,408 square feet of outstanding living space with virtually everything inside brand new! Featuring 3 bedrooms, including two on the main level, and 2 full baths, this home combines modern updates with exceptional space and flexibility. The spacious kitchen showcases new appliances and flows seamlessly into multiple gathering areas, including a living room, family room, dining room, and bonus room - providing endless options for entertaining, working, or relaxing. Need even more space? The unfinished area above the garage offers incredible potential for additional bedrooms, a recreation room, or guest suite. Situated on a large lot, you'll enjoy outdoor living with an open patio, wood deck, and fenced backyard. The oversized garage is great for hobbyists or business owners, featuring two separate workshop areas plus a dedicated office space. A rare opportunity to own a move-in ready home with room to grow, both inside and out!

504 E Park Street, Trafalgar

Listing courtesy of Carpenter, REALTORS®.

3 Beds ⋅ 4 Baths

Beautiful view of Lamb Lake on 1.58 wooded acres. Nicely updated 2 story w/walk out basement. Primary suite w/huge walk-in closet and full bath and lakeview from bedroom window. Darling reading nook or playroom on upper level. Roomy kitchen w/loads of counters, cabinets, center island & breakfast room opening to upper deck with lakeview. Spacious great room w/cozy gas fireplace and doors opening to upper deck. Formal Dining, office & half bath also on main level. Low maintenance upper deck installed in 2021 is approx 1,550 sq ft of outdoor entertainment space! Lower walkout level has laundry room, workshop, full bath, and 29x24 flex space for rec room, family room or whatever your needs may be! Opens to lower deck on lakeside to access hot tub & firepit sitting area for even more outdoor enjoyment! Stairway leads to boat parking in back of quiet cove. Hop in your boat and head out to enjoy boating, fishing, skiing, tubing, private beach, & wildlife on the finest private lake Indiana has to offer! Be sure to read attached list of Special Features & Updates

7899 S Timber Cliff Lane, Trafalgar

Listing courtesy of RE/MAX Advanced Realty.

3 Beds ⋅ 3 Baths

Nestled along the desirable north shore of Lamb Lake, this beautifully appointed 3-bedroom waterfront retreat offers the perfect opportunity to embrace lake living just in time for summer. Situated on .77 acres, this ranch-style home with a finished walkout basement combines comfort, privacy, and effortless access to the water. The spacious main-level primary suite serves as a peaceful sanctuary, featuring a luxurious en suite bath with jetted tub, separate shower, walk-in closet, cozy sitting area, and private access to the lakeside deck - the ideal setting for morning coffee overlooking the water. A second main-level bedroom with its own en suite bath provides comfort and convenience for guests or family. At the heart of the home, the open-concept living and kitchen area is highlighted by vaulted ceilings and a striking stone fireplace, creating a warm and inviting atmosphere for gathering and entertaining. The finished walkout lower level expands the living space with a generous family room, third bedroom, bonus room, full bath, and game area. Outside, thoughtfully designed outdoor living spaces blend natural beauty with functional hardscape and landscaping. Multiple decks and patios overlook the tranquil cove, while the lower patio with hot tub creates the perfect place to unwind after a day on the water. A gentle slope leads to the private dock and pontoon lift with minimal steps, making lake access exceptionally convenient. The calm cove waters are ideal for swimming, floating, and fishing right from your dock, while the main body of the lake is only a short 2-3 minute boat ride away. Whether you're seeking a weekend escape or a year-round waterfront residence, this exceptional property offers the perfect balance of relaxation, recreation, and refined lakefront living.

7592 S Poplar Point Drive, Trafalgar

Listing courtesy of Smythe & Co, Inc.

5 Beds ⋅ 3 Baths

DON'T MISS this practically NEW HOME in the lovely CRESTRIDGE ESTATES in TRAFALGAR! Built in 2023 and BOASTS over 2500 SQ FT! 5 BEDROOM, 2 1/2 BATH, OFFICE, LOFT/FLEX ROOM, 3 CAR GARAGE in the desirable INDIAN CREEK SCHOOLS district; WALKING DISTANCE to SCHOOL, WALKING PATH, BALL DIAMONDS and TENNIS COURTS! Exterior of the home is a beautiful stone and LP SmartSide Engineered wood siding. Home offers ABUNDANT storage with a Mud Room, Walk-in PANTRY, and WALK-IN CLOSETS. Family Room and Kitchen feel SO SPACIOUS with 9' ceilings, AND offer a GREAT VIEW of your PRIVATE BACKYARD and WOODS - NO NEIGHBORS behind you! The 5th bedroom is on the MAIN FLOOR in addition to a Sitting Room/Formal Dining Room/Office Space. The upstairs has an AMAZING FLEX AREA in the LOFT. Great option for an additional office, recreation, gaming, hangout, or even a possible bedroom. The MASTER SUITE is HUGE featuring a large bathroom that includes a walk-in shower, soaking tub, double marble vanity, walk-in closet and linen closet. The 2nd floor Laundry Room is definitely a great convenience. The OUTDOOR SPACE is a blank slate to create your own OASIS! Imagine PARTY LIGHTS throughout the TREES, FIREPIT rolling & ROASTING MARSHMALLOWS enjoying the peace of living in a country neighborhood. Or grab a cup of coffee and watch the world go by on your 20+ ft FRONT PORCH. Garage also includes a 30AMP Generator Hookup & Interlock Kit. This home is located just 2 minutes to SR135, 12 minutes to Franklin AND CAMP ATTERBURY, 30 minutes to the quaint town of NASHVILLE & COLUMBUS, 45 minutes to downtown INDY. INCLUDES BUILDERS 2-10 HOME WARRANTY.

48 Manchester Drive, Trafalgar

Listing courtesy of Keller Williams Indy Metro Partners.

Start Your Search

Information Deemed Reliable But Not Guaranteed. © 2026 MIBOR Broker Listing Cooperative