Columbus Homes with Cellar Basement

Columbus Homes with Cellar Basement

Welcome to Columbus, Indiana, a charming city known for its rich architectural heritage, vibrant arts scene, and welcoming community spirit. Nestled in the heart of the Midwest, Columbus is often celebrated for its innovative design and stunning buildings, with contributions from renowned architects like Eero Saarinen and I.M. Pei. As you stroll through the tree-lined streets, you'll discover a delightful mix of modern amenities and small-town charm, making it an ideal place to call home.

One of the unique features of homes in Columbus is the availability of properties with cellar basements. These versatile spaces provide extra storage, a cozy retreat, or the perfect area for a workshop or hobby room. Imagine transforming your cellar basement into a game room, a home gym, or even a serene wine cellar to showcase your collection. The possibilities are endless!

Columbus boasts a strong sense of community, with local parks, shops, and restaurants that cater to all tastes. The city hosts various events throughout the year, including art festivals and farmers' markets, fostering a warm and welcoming atmosphere for residents and visitors alike.

Whether you're seeking a family home, a charming bungalow, or a contemporary masterpiece, Columbus offers a diverse array of real estate options to suit your needs. With its unique cellar basements, you can enjoy the added benefit of functional space that enhances your living experience. Discover your dream home in Columbus, where comfort, creativity, and community come together seamlessly.

Newest Columbus Homes with Cellar Basement

3 Beds ⋅ 2 Baths

This is your opportunity to own a piece of Historic Downtown Columbus and enjoy one of the city's most vibrant, walkable neighborhoods. Surrounded by award-winning architecture, locally loved restaurants, coffee shops, boutiques, parks, and year-round community events, this is a location that inspires creativity and connection. Is it the best block in Columbus? Maybe! Inside, you'll find a beautifully updated 3-bedroom, 1-bath home paired with a turnkey 1-bedroom, 1-bath garage suite. Whether you're looking to generate income through a short-term rental, create a private space for guests, or want to use it as an office space, this unique property offers exceptional flexibility. Thoughtfully renovated (check out the incredible new hardwood floors!) while preserving its distinctive character, the home feels like a living work of art. Expansive gathering spaces inside and inviting outdoor entertaining areas featuring native flower beds make hosting friends and family effortless.This must be the place!

726 Lafayette Avenue, Columbus

Listing courtesy of 1 Percent Lists Indiana Real Estate.

1 Beds ⋅ 1 Baths

Attention investors, we have a charming little home that just needs some love. This one bedroom house could easily become a two bedroom home with just a few tweaks. Vaulted ceiling in the front part of the home allow for a larger feel when inside almost creating the illusion that there's a second story - although there isn't. It also has a decently sized back yard that has a privacy fence. Looking for conventional loans or cash buyers.

1448 Chestnut Street, Columbus

Listing courtesy of Keller Williams Indy Metro Partners.

4 Beds ⋅ 2 Baths

Step back in time-without giving up modern conveniences! Built in 1865, this stunning Victorian beauty sits proudly on 4.5 acres and is overflowing with the kind of character you simply can't build today. If walls could talk, these wallpaper-covered beauties would have some stories to tell! From the original hardwood floors and intricate woodwork to the timeless trim details throughout, this home is a dream for anyone who appreciates historic charm and craftsmanship. The spacious second floor features 3 bedrooms, a huge remodeled full bath complete with a clawfoot tub, separate shower, and enough space to make your morning routine feel like a spa day. Need extra room? The bonus room offers endless possibilities for a 4th bedroom, home office, craft room, or whatever your imagination can dream up. On the main level, you'll find a welcoming living room, formal dining room, cozy den/library, and a beautifully remodeled kitchen featuring stainless steel appliances ready for your next family gathering or holiday feast. Step outside and the possibilities continue. Whether you're dreaming of a hobby farm, workshop space, storage for your toys and equipment, or simply room to spread out, this property delivers. The 4.5-acre setting includes three barns, a covered equipment barn, and a detached garage, offering an abundance of functional space rarely found with a home of this era. Major updates have already been taken care of, including a brand-new roof in 2025 and replacement windows throughout the home. Historic homes like this don't come along every day. Whether you're a lover of Victorian architecture, original woodwork, or simply want a home with personality that can't be found in a cookie-cutter subdivision, this one is a must-see to truly appreciate. Come prepared to fall in love-and maybe leave wanting to keep the wallpaper just for the stories it tells!

6631 E 800 N, Columbus

Listing courtesy of Plum Tree Realty.

1 Beds ⋅ 1 Baths

If you've been looking for a place that's fully updated and ready to move right into, this is it. The house has been recently renovated and features a really great layout with one main bedroom plus a versatile bonus room that would make a perfect home office or guest space. The heart of the home is definitely the kitchen-it has a ton of space and a big center island that's perfect for cooking and hanging out. You won't run out of storage either, thanks to a large attic with pull-down stairs and a cellar with exterior access that keeps all the utilities out of your way. Outside, you get covered front and back porches to relax on, and a spacious backyard that already has a handy storage shed. Plus, there is plenty of room back there if you want to build a garage down the road or just customize the space to make it your own.

1941 Wallace Avenue, Columbus

Listing courtesy of eXp Realty LLC.

3 Beds ⋅ 1 Baths

Downtown Columbus: Historic 3 bedroom home with an 18x24 detached garage built in 2001, a large privacy-fenced yard, and two storage buildings in excellent condition (the larger of the two has electric). Spacious and sunny rooms including a big mudroom/laundry room by the back door. Older homes need maintenance and this home has had it: New gas furnace and central air in 2019. Roof 2019. All knob and tube wiring has been disconnected and replaced. The original wooden joists have been professionally reinforced. The old wooden front porch and steps have been replaced with concrete. Vinyl siding, replacement windows (2002), nice updates to the kitchen, and the bathroom has double sinks and a walk-in showed with a glass door. The history of Hutchins Avenue in Columbus might surprise you. The neighborhood was called Maple Grove. Alonozo Butler built 634 Hutchins from 1890-1892 then passed away unexpectedly in 1895. His wife and later his daughter continued to live in the home, and 634 Hutchins became part of the Columbus ladies' social scene: In 1917 it was a home where meetings of the WTCU (Woman's Christian Temperance Union) were held, but by the 1920s, regular meetings of the Happy Hour Club were held there! By 1947 it was and the Maple Grove Beauty Shop. This house still has so much original character: tall ceilings, custom wood trim, hardwood floors, and big rooms. Horses aren't kept out back any more, but there is a big detached garage and a large privacy-fenced backyard. Many of the nieghboring homes have also been updated recently. Come see what downtown Columbus has to offer within easy walking distance of this home.

634 Hutchins Avenue, Columbus

Listing courtesy of 1 Percent Lists Indiana Real Estate.

3 Beds ⋅ 1 Baths

Completely remodeled down to the studs, this beautifully updated 3-bedroom, 1-bath home at 2215 Cherry Street offers the perfect blend of modern finishes and everyday convenience. Nearly every aspect of the home has been updated, including flooring, paint, and numerous additional upgrades throughout.The interior features a fresh, clean design with functional living spaces and an efficient layout. Outside, enjoy a fenced rear yard-ideal for pets, outdoor gatherings, or added privacy-along with a detached one-car garage for parking or storage. Located in a highly convenient area, this home is just minutes from Kroger, approximately 5 minutes to downtown Columbus, and about 3 minutes to Donner Park. Easy access to shopping, dining, and recreation makes this an excellent option for a wide range of buyers. Move-in ready with modern updates and a prime location-don't miss this opportunity.

2215 N Cherry Street, Columbus

Listing courtesy of Dean Wagner LLC.

3 Beds ⋅ 2 Baths

Exceptional 91-Acre Farmstead - Modern Utility, Versatile Outbuildings, and Endless Potential. Discover the perfect balance of modern comfort and rural functionality on this impressive 91-acre property, thoughtfully designed for agricultural, equestrian, or hobby farm pursuits. With extensive infrastructure, quality outbuildings, and multiple fenced pastures, this estate offers exceptional versatility and opportunity. The residence features a 200-amp electrical service, central air conditioning, and a gas furnace, complemented by an outside central boiler wood burner for efficient, cost-effective heating. The home is connected to public water, with a well serving as an alternate supply. All exterior water hydrants are connected to the well-providing consistent and convenient water access throughout the property. Outbuildings & Features: Pole Barn #1 (64' x 64') - Gravel floor, two hay lofts, four sliding doors, one man door, water hydrant, and direct pasture access. Pole Barn #2 (64' x 40') - Gravel floor, two sliding doors, two swing doors, one man door, water hydrant, and access to two pastures. Pole Barn #3 (24' x 36') - Gravel floor, two sliding doors, one man door, water hydrant, and pasture access. Detached Garage (22' x 32' with 20' x 18' addition) - Two 16' overhead doors, two man doors, concrete flooring, and a new roof, perfect for vehicles, equipment, or workshop use. Dog Kennel (12' x 32') - Four kennels with concrete outside runs, a 12' x 12' office area, and three man doors. Chicken Coop/Barn (20' x 24') - Multiple fenced pastures, strategically placed water hydrants, and abundant storage and livestock facilities make this property ideal for those seeking a working farm, equestrian operation, or peaceful country lifestyle.

6951 W 450 S, Columbus

Listing courtesy of RE/MAX Real Estate Prof.

Start Your Search

Information Deemed Reliable But Not Guaranteed. © 2026 MIBOR Broker Listing Cooperative